Same Keywords, Higher CPCs: What It Means for PPC Management
Agency data on 14 B2B advertisers shows the same non-brand keywords cost about 21% more year over year. Here is what I would check in your account.
Agency data on 14 B2B advertisers shows the same non-brand keywords cost about 21% more year over year. Here is what I would check in your account.
An agency report from Grey Matter looked at 14 B2B Google Ads advertisers and found that the same non-brand keywords cost about 21% more per click than a year earlier, even after controlling for their own spend, position and Quality Score. It also found that advertisers who spent more paid noticeably more for the same clicks. For anyone doing PPC management for B2B accounts, this is a useful reference point for 2027 budget conversations. It is not a forecast for your account.
Most CPC benchmarks give you one average and stop there. That average mixes two things: the market getting more expensive, and advertisers buying different clicks than last year. This report tried to separate the two.
The setup, in short:
Without any controls, the same keywords cost 29% more. Controlling for spend and impression share lost to budget brought that to 22%, and adding top-of-page position and Quality Score brought it to 21%.
The likely range is wide: 1% to 44%. Remove the biggest spender and the estimate drops to about 17%, with a range that includes zero. Add broad match keywords back in and it rises to about 31%. The report's own author says the true figure "could be meaningfully higher or lower". I think that honesty is the most useful part of the report. Read it as a direction, not a number to plug into a spreadsheet.
The second finding matters more for day-to-day Google Ads management. In the regression, every 10% increase in campaign spend went with about 1.4% higher CPCs on top of the market increase. Doubling spend meant roughly 11% higher CPCs. The report gives no range for that figure.
The extreme case in the sample nearly quadrupled its non-brand Search spend, and its same-keyword CPCs rose 132%. Its brand keywords, on a flat budget, rose about 4% in the third quarter.
The report links this to automated bidding. If a campaign on Maximize Conversions gets a bigger budget, it spends it by entering auctions it used to skip: higher positions, more competitive searches, pricier times of day. That matches what we see in accounts. Extra budget on Max Conversions rarely buys more of the same clicks. It buys more expensive ones.
For 11 advertisers with enough matching keywords, the report built a keyword price index. Their average non-brand CPC rose 36% overall, and the report split that up like this:
| Component | Points of the 36% increase |
|---|---|
| Market (same keywords) | +22 |
| Higher spending | +3 |
| Keyword, match type and bid strategy changes | -3 |
| Not explained (mostly a few advertisers, likely category competition) | +14 |
Individual results ranged from a 30% decrease to a 121% increase. Ten of the 11 paid more for the same keywords, nine paid more overall. One advertiser kept spend flat, saw its same keywords rise 20%, then moved budget towards pricier phrase-match keywords and ended up with a 40% higher overall CPC. Same market, different decisions, very different account average.
A few things I would keep in mind.
Higher CPC is not automatically bad. The report has no conversion rate or cost per lead data, so it cannot tell you whether these advertisers got worse results. Under Smart Bidding, a rising CPC can go with a stable or better CPA. I would always judge the account on CPA or ROAS, not on CPC alone.
Do not compare your CPC with Google's number. Alphabet's Q3 10-Q shows Search CPC up 4% year over year, but that is click revenue divided by paid clicks across all advertisers, devices and markets. It measures something else entirely, so it neither confirms nor contradicts the 21%.
Scale budgets in steps. The report's guidance is to increase budgets gradually and judge each step by what the additional clicks cost. I agree. If the last 20% of budget brings leads at twice the average CPA, the blended number will hide it for a while.
Price the extra conversions first. On Max Conversions, decide what an additional lead is worth to you before raising the budget, then set a tCPA to match. Without a target, the algorithm will spend the money, and it will find expensive auctions to do it.
This is a check any in-house team can run in an afternoon:
If your reporting makes this hard, the problem is usually the data setup, not the analysis. Clean conversion tracking matters here, which is where solid GA4 and conversion tracking pays for itself. For recurring checks, a dashboard beats a manual export, as we did in our automated Google Ads and GA4 reporting project for eOptika.
Rising CPCs are not something you can switch off. What you can control is how you scale, which auctions you let automated bidding enter, and whether you notice early when marginal clicks stop being worth it. That is most of what good PPC management looks like in a market like this.
If your in-house team has the time and the data, you can run all of the above yourselves. If not, a PPC agency or Google Ads agency should be able to show you same-keyword and marginal-cost views, not just a blended CPC trend. That is how we approach our PPC management services, especially for B2B accounts heading into budget planning.
In Grey Matter's data on 14 B2B advertisers, the same non-brand keywords cost about 21% more year over year after controls, with a likely range of 1% to 44%. It is a reference point from one agency's clients, not a forecast for any single account.
In that report, every 10% increase in campaign spend went with about 1.4% higher CPCs on the same keywords. The likely reason is that automated bidding like Maximize Conversions enters more competitive auctions when it has more budget.
In my view, judge the account on CPA or ROAS rather than CPC, scale budgets in steps and check what each additional click costs. On Max Conversions, decide what extra conversions are worth and set a target before raising the budget.
Source: Higher Spend Came With Pricier Clicks For 14 B2B Google Advertisers (Search Engine Journal)